Over the past few weeks, I have been reading what initially felt like divergent conversations and views about the future of philanthropy.
In one corner, there are conversations about scarcity. Development funding has shrunk, nonprofits are competing harder for grants, and organisations that have spent years working on health, livelihoods, governance, gender justice, agriculture and civic participation are trying to work out how they will continue doing so with less certainty about future resourcing.
In another corner, there are conversations about sustainability. Nonprofits are being encouraged to diversify their income. To think about services they could charge for, develop products, attract individual donors, build reserves, or even to collaborate more closely with others. Increasingly there are conversations and not-so-gentle nudges to consider whether mergers might make sense.
Then there is another conversation happening within philanthropy itself. Funders are talking more seriously about systems change, long-term capital, institutional strengthening, locally led development, flexible funding, impact investing and how philanthropic capital might do more than simply fund projects.
Taken separately, each of these conversations makes sense. Taken together though, they leave me with a question.
If the problems we are trying to solve are increasingly understood as systemic, then why does so much of the funding architecture around them still behave transactionally?
There really is less money in parts of the system
I start here because otherwise this becomes an easy argument about funders simply refusing to release money that is readily available. The reality is more complicated.
Official development assistance fell sharply. According to the OECD’s 2026 projections, net ODA fell by 23.3% in 2025, the largest annual contraction on record, after falling in 2024. It is projected to decline by a further 6.9% in 2026. Bilateral ODA to sub-Saharan Africa fell by an estimated 26.3% in 2025 and is projected to fall another 11.6% this year.
These are not marginal adjustments. They represent a significant contraction in a development system that many organisations, programmes and governments have depended on for decades.
And while ODA and philanthropy are not the same thing, they operate within the same development ecosystem. When government development assistance contracts, organisations inevitably look elsewhere. Foundations receive more applications. Existing philanthropic budgets are stretched across more needs. Funders that previously complemented public development finance suddenly find themselves being asked to replace parts of it.
The Center for Effective Philanthropy’s 2026 survey captures some of that pressure. Fifty-seven percent of nonprofit CEOs surveyed said foundation grants had become harder to secure since January 2025, while 44% reported reduced funding from foundations. So yes, there is genuine scarcity, but that is really not the whole story.
There is also capital in the system. The question is how it moves.
The OECD’s latest major examination of private philanthropy for development gives us another part of the picture I’m trying to paint for you.
Between 2020 and 2023, private philanthropy contributed an estimated $68.2 billion to development, including $52.8 billion in cross-border funding. Africa was the largest recipient region, receiving $17.6 billion, or approximately one-third of those cross-border flows. But where the money goes is only half the story because how it gets there matters just as much.
Of the cross-border philanthropic funding examined by the OECD, 89% was channelled through international entities. Only 11% went directly through local entities. The OECD is careful to acknowledge that international intermediaries may subsequently regrant some of those resources locally, meaning the amount eventually spent locally could be higher. But the first point of control remains overwhelmingly international. That immediately raises questions about proximity, decision-making and power.
| Who defines the problem? Who determines which organisations are considered capable of solving it? Who controls the resources? How many institutional layers must these funds pass through before reaching the people working closest to the issue? And how much organisational energy is spent proving eligibility to systems that may themselves be structurally distant from the reality they are trying to address? |
With these questions in mind, let’s take a look at the conversation about localisation.
Publish What You Fund examined $5.2 billion in project-type spending from five major bilateral donors and found that only 5.5% (i.e. $287 million) went directly to local organisations in the sample it studied. Again, bilateral aid is not philanthropy. But the pattern across the wider development-finance ecosystem is difficult to ignore. We talk increasingly about local leadership while maintaining financial architectures in which relatively little money moves directly to local actors and actual local work.
Accessing what is available is itself strenuous work
As we look at the system, let’s not forget something that deserves attention too: the cost of trying to get funded.
Candid’s research among nearly 4,000 U.S.-based nonprofits found that among organisations that had stopped applying for foundation grants, lack of capacity to apply was the most commonly cited reason. Fifty-seven percent of those organisations said they lacked the staff, time or resources needed to pursue grants. Some organisations described repeatedly translating their work into different funder languages and formats, often after previous applications had resulted in rejection with little useful feedback. I would dare say that this could apply across much of the global majority as well. Every additional hoop that organisations have to go through has an opportunity cost.
For a large institution with a development department, completing another bespoke application may be irritating. For a small organisation with three people, it may mean the executive director stops delivering programmes for several days to write a proposal that has a relatively small probability of being funded.
Then we wonder why small organisations have weak systems. This is a contradiction I keep wondering if the ecosystem sees, recognises and appreciates enough to do something about it.
We want local organisations to:
- strengthen their financial systems,
- build good governance,
- improve monitoring and evaluation,
- retain capable staff,
- develop communications functions,
- invest in safeguarding,
- learn continuously and
- demonstrate increasingly sophisticated evidence of impact
But many of those organisations are funded primarily to deliver activities. Meanwhile, the organisation itself remains underfunded.
The West Africa Civil Society Institute’s 2026 assessment of 693 Nigerian civil-society organisations describes this particularly clearly. WACSI identifies what it calls a systemic “starvation cycle” in which chronic underfunding weakens organisations’ institutional capacity, which then makes it more difficult for them to demonstrate impact, mobilise resources and become resilient. That is not a capacity issue, it is a funding-system problem.
Perhaps this is why the philanthropy conversation is beginning to shift
It is not all gloom though because fortunately, this year, many organisations within philanthropy itself are beginning to say versions of the same thing.
In September, UNDP and Temasek Trust published From Silos to Systems, Projects to Portfolios. They make the case that philanthropy needs to move beyond funding isolated projects and instead organise capital around systems. Their argument is that complex development challenges cannot be adequately addressed through disconnected interventions. Funders need to think about portfolios of activity, institutional relationships, markets, infrastructure, learning and how different interventions reinforce one another over time.
At Project by Projects our recommendation in fact is to build the impact community before the grant portfolio. We break down a clear framework too for how this might be done in practice.
FSG has similarly been examining what it calls a broader “palette” of approaches available to funders seeking systems change. Rather than seeing the foundation primarily as the institution that funds programmes, it asks funders to consider how they might strengthen leaders, organisations, networks, markets, policy environments and other conditions required for change. NPC is even more direct. Its recent work argues that traditional short-term and heavily restricted grants can actively undermine systems change because they restrict organisations’ ability to adapt, collaborate, learn and respond to changing conditions.
And the evidence coming from nonprofits themselves points in the same direction. Bridgespan’s 2026 research across Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore found that seven in ten nonprofit leaders identified lack of long-term, flexible funding as a critical constraint on their ability to build capacity and scale impact.
I share these examples because, obviously, something is shifting. The sector is beginning to recognise that funding programmes without strengthening the systems around them may produce activity without necessarily producing resilience.
Sustainability cannot simply become another burden transferred to nonprofits
There is also a parallel conversation about what nonprofits themselves should do differently.
| Diversify revenue. Charge for services where appropriate. Develop products. Build individual giving. Explore membership. Create social enterprises. Build reserves. Share services. Collaborate. Merge. |
While some of the advice, subtle or not, does make sense, we should be careful about where this argument takes us. A nonprofit that has developed significant expertise in training, research, facilitation, technology, publishing or another service should certainly be able to ask whether some of that capability can generate revenue. Organisations should think about financial resilience, just as any institution should. BUT, BUT, BUT Not every public good has a market!
There is no obvious commercial revenue model for an organisation protecting civic space in a repressive environment. A women’s rights organisation supporting survivors may be serving precisely the people least able to pay. Independent accountability work is valuable partly because it can challenge powerful institutions without relying on those institutions as customers. Community organisations serving extremely poor populations cannot simply convert beneficiaries into consumers because donor funding has dried up.
If we are not careful, the drum we beat in saying “nonprofits need to become sustainable” can become a new and convenient way of transferring responsibility for a funding-system failure onto the organisations already living its consequences.
The same tensions repeat in the emerging conversation about mergers. The Chronicle of Philanthropy has reported increasing interest among funders in nonprofit consolidation, including a $1 million collaboration fund supported by the Ford and MacArthur foundations to help organisations manage the real costs of collaboration and consolidation.
There may be organisations for which merging is absolutely the right strategic decision. There may be others that can share infrastructure, collaborate more deeply or stop duplicating work without becoming one institution. However, the systems question here is not simply whether and how nonprofits should restructure themselves, but is philanthropy equally willing to restructure the funding architecture around them?
Systems-building: something different for philanthropy
If we genuinely mean systems change, then strengthening an institution cannot be treated as a distraction from impact because it is part of the system producing the impact.
To deliver sustainable impact, the organisation needs strong leadership, staff retention, effective governance, a system to generate and use evidence, a strong financial system and so on. The trust it has built with communities matters. Its relationships with other organisations matter. The knowledge it has accumulated over ten or twenty years also matters. None of those things are “overheads” sitting around the programme. Together, they form a critical backbone. That backbone will determine whether or not the organisation has the ability to adapt when its political, economic or social environment changes.
Reading from the field today, this is perhaps the shift philanthropy is really being asked to make: to intentionally and honestly begin asking “What needs to be strong in this system for meaningful change to endure?”
There are different constellations through which this can happen. From a project to a specific type of organization or network of organizations and even to shared data infrastructure, a coalition, a research function, leadership development, an advocacy ecosystem, long-term flexible capital or the connective tissue that allows actors who already understand the problem to work together more effectively.
Systems thinking means understanding how the pieces depend on one another before deciding which one deserves investment. It is not ‘forever funding’ but it is long term.
The scarcity question therefore needs to change
I had started exploring my readings and understanding of the lay of the land with what seemed like a contradiction. How can organisations experience such profound scarcity while considerable capital still exists across the philanthropic system?
Yet, I conclude now that the evidence suggests that this is partly the wrong question. What we should be asking is:
“Where does capital sit, how does it move, and what does the architecture reward?”
Because scarcity at the point of implementation is currently coexisting perfectly well with significant capital elsewhere in the system. This means that funds can exist through commitments and yet still be inefficiently disbursed or difficult to access.
On top of that, funds can be restricted so tightly that they deliver a project while leaving the institution delivering it weaker.
And funds can finance outputs repeatedly without ever investing in the networks, institutions, relationships and learning required to change the conditions producing the problem in the first place.
None of this suggests that philanthropy can replace government. It cannot, and it should not.
Governments remain responsible for health systems, education, agricultural development, economic opportunity, justice, infrastructure and the protection of citizens’ rights. Philanthropy cannot become an alternative state.
But across Africa, Asia and many other parts of the world, nonprofit and civil-society organisations are often standing precisely at the point where those large systems meet people’s everyday lives. They are translating policy, filling gaps, organising communities, testing solutions, producing evidence, challenging power and keeping issues visible long enough for institutions to respond.
If we believe those organisations are part of the infrastructure of development, then perhaps we need to stop funding them as though they are temporary delivery vehicles.
If we continue trying to solve structural problems with transactional tools, we should not be surprised when the projects end and the problems remain.
Still listening. Still learning. Now asking!
| For donors building a grant portfolio? Project by Projects works with funders to think beyond individual grants and design portfolios around the systems, relationships, institutions and conditions needed for lasting impact. We can support your portfolio building process For funders seeing these shifts from inside the system, I would like to hear from you. Oryonor is gathering perspectives on how grantmaking is changing, where the friction sits, and what better funding systems could look like. Share your perspective through our research. For nonprofits and civil-society organisations on the receiving end of these funding systems, your experience matters too. Oryonor is gathering the realities of applying for, accessing and managing funding so we can better understand what organisations actually need to become stronger and more sustainable. Share your experience and help us build a clearer picture of what needs to change. |

